Originally Posted by doublevanosrc
The whole door would have to be resprayed.
+1. Plus the panels next to the door will need to be blended.
IF your car was not painted while in your hands... perhaps the car was painted before you took delivery, like while in shipping transit to the dealer or while the dealer had it on the lot. Sometimes if the repair was cheap... the dealer or BMW might not need to disclosed this fact to you. I think only when the repair is more than 6% of the value of the car. But I think that varies state by state.
You will need a new paint job, sorry buddy.