I'm also sort of coming from a Porsche (had an Audi also) and am in agreement with this original review. Other than the motor, my One is much more comparable to my Audi than my Porsche But for the price, etc, that's what I expected. I'd still rank my One as one of or maybe even the best daily driver ever. I did change to KW V1's and now my ride is nearly as stiff as my Porsche 968 but with more roll. It's now probably not as good of a daily driver now but I like it better. I'll probably upgrade my front sway bar soon.
I really love the N54 and it's potential. The headlights are incredible. My least favorite features are the small gas tank and fuel pump concerns.