So true, they look terrible on the site but in person, like you said, they're a completely different wheel. I've had plenty of compliments on them and I'm just like, shrug, eh yea they're nice haha.
I was VERY close to pulling the trigger on the Coral Red. I bailed and went black / white trim which I love, but it is very nice as well in the Coral and you're going to love it!
Good luck with it!