View Single Post
      06-20-2011, 08:57 AM   #48
banglemangle
Lieutenant
Azerbaijan
15
Rep
576
Posts

Drives: bmw135
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: Somewhere on the East Coast of Australia

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by bfi2906 View Post
Sharing in case this is helpful to others ......

I've just priced my renewal for a 2009 manual 135 coupe - agreed value of $60K, including hire car, one excess free glass claim per year and NCB protection, no drivers under 25, garaged and private use

RYNO (current insurer) - $1550.09 with $500 excess
BMW - $1961.70 with a $650 excess
GIO - $1517.61, or $1459.28 (with CTP) with a $600 excess
Coles (Northshore special) - started at $1414, but adding the hirecar, glass & protecting NCB, it ended at $2090 with a $650 excess

Interesting that, if I use their own numbers, they value the hire car at $76, the no excess glass claim at $61 and the protected NCB at 10% of premium - $177. That all adds to $314, plus the original estimate of $1414, for a total of $1728.

Not the final quote of $2090 - which is supposed to include a 10% discount for purchasing online. Granted it includes free roadside assistance that I don't want, and some once a month fuel discount - say $4.18 in value (what BS!!!)

So I guess the lesson is, look closely at the Coles offer - even the basic numbers don't add up.
Interesting. I switched the playdo from gio (990 prem) to coles (600 prem) for 55k insured, 500 deductable.

Noddy car is 1400 @ coles, 1050 @ gio. go figure!
Appreciate 0