Quote:
Originally Posted by IndyMike
80% of those on this board that move from manual to DCT will be back to manual within 3 to 4 years.
I've got its VAG counterpart, and have been using it as my DD for 3 years now. It's a great transmission and has been a real joy to use in that time period. I really don't have anything bad to say about it.
But like any video game you use every day the thrill eventually gets driven away (pun intended). If anything because it is in fact too good.
If I didn't have the manny tranny einser to play with on the weekends I would probably go 
The gearbox is the best I've ever experienced in any BMW of the past 20 years, and finding the desired gear is not a struggle as it used to be.
But even with that benefit it still offers extreme challenges.
And in the end I prefer challenging myself rather than some computer, even if it beats me 99% of the time. Because that 1 time I beat it it will be nirvana and pure sweetness.
So go ahead and stray from the path if you feel compelled, but once the thrill is gone I'm guessing like the Prodigal Son you'll be back.............. in 3 years................maybe 4 years..............TOPS!
 |
I agree.
I don't doubt that the DCT shifts faster than I do or that it picks the right gear more often than I. It's faster 0-60 and quite possibly the best auto transmission out there.
But in a small car (like a 135i) I really want a manual transmission. Move up to the 5 or 7 Series, I get it.
But I'd pay more money for a manual than a DCT.