I think you guys are right. My SA asked me specifically if I've owned the car since new and/or have ever had it repainted. If it was done, must have been during shipping, though - I would think BMW would still be liable, but we'll see if they try to weasel out of it or not. Hoping for at least a goodwill repair on their part.
I guess worst case scenario is I pick up an M-Sport or Performance bumper to replace this one...spendy, though.
__________________
____________________________
|