|
|
|
08-17-2010, 12:57 PM | #23 |
Brigadier General
368
Rep 3,547
Posts |
I should have mentioned this in my first post but there is an excellant article in last month's, July's, Roundel magazine. I think even non-members can get to the on line versions if you go to the BMW car club of america website. Mike Miller, who writes the maintenance column for the Roundel (he answered two of my emails the next day in both cases) calls the 128i the most fun of any current BMW. He includes data from a test on a track where the 128i was about 5mph slower in top speed to a couple much bigger, much more expensive bimmers but I do not remember the models. I think it was 130mph versus 135mph or something like that. Mike also comments that while it understeers at the limits the limits are so high most drivers will not get there.
I got the sports suspension as one of only two extras I ordered (the other was walnut trim). I like Mike's column, and his support, and I agree completely with the article he wrote (it is the first I've seen him write). Jim
__________________
128i Convertible, MT, Alpine White, Black Top, Taupe Leatherette, Walnut, Sport
Ordered 5/22/09, Completed 6/4/09, At Port 6/9/09, On the Georgia Highway 6/13/09, Ship Arrived Charleston 6/24/09 at 10pm, PCD 7/21/09 |
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 01:29 PM | #24 |
Lieutenant
38
Rep 456
Posts |
Everything I can think of was already said. I drove both. Got the 128i. Love it. I couldn't be happier. The article in the Roundel magazine that JimD mentioned is something you need to read if you are considering this car.
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 01:32 PM | #25 | |
Second Lieutenant
13
Rep 246
Posts |
Quote:
-dave |
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 01:38 PM | #26 |
Lieutenant Colonel
102
Rep 1,552
Posts
Drives: '19 M2C | '20 100AE ND2
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Phx, AZ
|
Even with that thread popping up about a possible HPFP problem on the N55, there's still no way I would have considered a 128 instead of a 135 (I would have went with a base Cayman instead.) The 135 is just a lot more fun and isn't even much more money. I think the HPFP problem is blown out of proportion. I know of 2 '09s and an '08 locally. Both '09s have had 1 HPFP replacement and the '08 hasn't had any problems. My car hasn't had any problems either. It happens sometimes, but not as often as some people make it out to be. The owners of the '09s shrugged it off like it wasn't a big deal when I asked them about it. Both are nearing 30k miles.
That being said, I'm still extremely happy about my choice and if I do have a problem in the future, so be it. At least it seems BMW has claimed to fix the problem with the new "402" pumps.
__________________
2019 M2C - Alpine White - 6MT
2023 Supra 6MT - Deposit and Wait |
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 01:59 PM | #27 |
Captain
11
Rep 685
Posts
Drives: 91 300ZX Twin-Turbo, 2010 135i
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Corpus Christi, Texas
|
To be honest, I would never consider a 128i. If you want reliable performance in a platform that is tougher, for the same $$ or less, that uses a TRULY good sounding and radical naturally aspirated I6, buy an E46 M3.
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 02:02 PM | #28 | |
Second Lieutenant
13
Rep 246
Posts |
I'd love to go with a Caymen, but by the time I get done with the options it's about $80k Damn Porsche and their infinite list of options! Yet it annoys me that BMW doesn't give me better ala-cart options, go figure.
Quote:
I think there is enough information out there to say that the HPFP is indeed a real problem for BMW that they haven't proven (yet) that they can fix. No it hasn't happened to everyone, but will it break for them tomorrow or last until the rest of the engine dies of old age? If I'm going to gamble, I'd like to actually be able to win something in the end When SAs are even advising against 35s due to the issues, that's pretty telling in my opinion. My wife's SA flat out told me not to get a 135 when we told him I was looking at a 1. I told him I was only looking at the N55 as I was hoping the issue was resolved, but he was still of the opinion that he would stay away from it for now. -dave |
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 02:06 PM | #29 |
Major
124
Rep 1,362
Posts |
Just another input, but as a man if I was gonna buy something sporty I will always buy the sportier engine. It's like a man buying a V6 mustang or camaro what's the point? That's just how I feel.
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 02:07 PM | #30 |
Second Lieutenant
13
Rep 246
Posts |
From what I hear that isn't a group of words that belongs in the same sentence
If I'm going for an old BMW, I'm getting another e30IX. Damn I miss that car. The problem is finding one that isn't too badly rusted out that the owner is willing to part with I've actually taken to flagging down e30iX owners I pass on the road and ask them if they'd be willing to sell it, no luck so far -dave |
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 02:09 PM | #31 | |
Captain
11
Rep 685
Posts
Drives: 91 300ZX Twin-Turbo, 2010 135i
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Corpus Christi, Texas
|
Quote:
Maybe he doesn't want to deal with warranty issues? First off, it's covered for a long time, and even if you are out of warranty there are already manuals/DIYs on how to replace it yourself. Secondly, if it happens repeatedly, BMW will buy the car back or you can sue. Last of all, there MUST be some point in time when a "bullet-proof" HPFP comes out, whether it be BMW's or an upgraded aftermarket unit. I have been 18,000 miles with no issues. 135i |
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 02:10 PM | #32 | |
Lieutenant Colonel
102
Rep 1,552
Posts
Drives: '19 M2C | '20 100AE ND2
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Phx, AZ
|
Quote:
__________________
2019 M2C - Alpine White - 6MT
2023 Supra 6MT - Deposit and Wait |
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 02:13 PM | #33 | |
Captain
11
Rep 685
Posts
Drives: 91 300ZX Twin-Turbo, 2010 135i
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Corpus Christi, Texas
|
Quote:
Also, if you neglect general maintenance, like not replacing or checking anything after 100,000 miles of driving, especially with a 3.2 I6 that revs to 8K, and something "lets go", is that poor engineering or owner stupidity? |
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 02:20 PM | #34 |
Second Lieutenant
13
Rep 246
Posts |
Or he could recognize that dealing with the issue is a hassle that many people just don't want to deal with.
I have gone through lemoning a car before (my first car actually). While it can be as simple as walking into a good dealership and saying "lemon", it can also be a nasty battle if they want to fight it (assuming that you really do qualify for the lemon law). Doubt he is trying to push it since I wouldn't expect him to get anything out of it and my CA is pushing the 135. If both were pushing the 128 I could see that maybe the dealer could have other motives, but given their opposing view points I believe it's just his honest opinion. |
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 02:26 PM | #35 |
Captain
11
Rep 685
Posts
Drives: 91 300ZX Twin-Turbo, 2010 135i
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Corpus Christi, Texas
|
My honest opinion is that you will enjoy the turbo or twin turbo engines much more, especially when you start playing with mods.
Good luck with your purchase! |
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 02:29 PM | #36 | |
!
693
Rep 3,266
Posts
Drives: 2010 128i
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: Anacortes, WA
|
Quote:
To the OP, if you get the 128i, the major thing to avoid is over-optioning the car, as you quickly erode any price advantage it has over the 135i. I'd say 6MT, sport package, and xenons are must-haves, they really contribute to the "driver's car" feel. I like that my 128i is simple. I really think it's a purist's car. I have no reason to do 0-60 in under 5 seconds (just under 6 is perfectly fine with me) and I plan to hold on to this thing for many years. The 135i just didn't make sense for me. Also, I would feel ripped off if I paid $40k+ for a 1er. I paid a hair over $30k and am perfectly content with that.
__________________
____________________________ |
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 02:59 PM | #37 |
Second Lieutenant
6
Rep 207
Posts |
Some say... that they prefer the N52.
Agree that the 128i is more of a purist driver's car. My experience with test drives of both cars is that the 128i feels notably lighter on its feet, very composed on the Sport Suspension, and has a more rewarding power delivery (better sound as the I6 revs, increasing power to redline). The car is by no means slow, incidentally, at least if equipped with the 6-speed manual gearbox. I have to smile when people say that a 230hp compact sized car that does 6-flat to 60mph is "slow", particularly a car with 50/50 weight distribution, RWD, a slick manual shifter, very quick steering ratio, and a suspension with very good ride/handling balance.
It is not about "settling"... there are several enthusiasts on this forum that genuinely prefer a naturally aspirated motor to a turbocharged one, and consequently find the N52-powered 1's more enjoyable to drive than the N54/N55-powered cars. Also, don't forget that you are not choosing a car to please either camp of 1-series owners, you are choosing the car that you will enjoy driving and owning, even years from now when many on this forum have moved on to other cars. |
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 03:14 PM | #38 | |
Major
124
Rep 1,362
Posts |
Quote:
My point is that why buy somthing sporty if your not gonna get the sportier motor. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 03:38 PM | #39 |
!
693
Rep 3,266
Posts
Drives: 2010 128i
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: Anacortes, WA
|
Note that I said "cheaper to own and maintain," so the 135i's higher short-term cost stems from its higher MSRP. Short-term maintenance is a non-issue because of the warranty, as you said, unless of course you consider time wasted, which is not inconsequential (time is money, after all).
From my perspective, BMW could extend the HPFP warranty out to 100 years and it still wouldn't make the N54 any more reliable. I simply don't want to pay that kind of money for a car and have to worry about whether or not the thing is going to start in the morning. I realize that not everyone has the HPFP issues, and I'm definitely not knocking the 135 - just saying that, for me, I was not ready to pay more money for a car that I viewed as less reliable. Plus, no one does NA I6's like BMW. As for your need to have the sportiest model offered - all I can say is that that sort of thinking makes you a marketer's dream. Once the 1M is on the market, will you say that the 135i is not worth having? Will your car somehow become slower simply because a faster model is available? Manufacturers are good at coming up with clever ways to part us from our money, and there will always be something out there that is newer, faster, or whatever. I simply decided how much I was willing to spend on a compact entry-level coupe and the 135i was beyond that. It's a personal decision that everyone has to make for themselves - for me, I have no regrets about my decision and don't feel like I've settled in any way.
__________________
____________________________ |
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 03:52 PM | #40 | |
Old Soul
15
Rep 274
Posts |
Quote:
The HPFP is just not as big of a deal as some on this site believe. It is a problem, and it is warrantied to 100,000 miles - 2x what the majority of people that currently own the 135i will drive it. I'd really love to learn what the true failure rate is from BMW, because nobody I know personally (including myself) has the problem. Again, I'm not saying nobody has it, but this board is not a good representation of the total BMW 135i population. So far I've had more problems with my clutch and waterpump than the HPFP. I'm not going to say that BMW clutches and waterpumps are crap, because I had a problem, either. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 04:14 PM | #41 | |
Major
124
Rep 1,362
Posts |
Quote:
But that's just my opinion on sports cars/coupes. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 04:23 PM | #42 |
Captain
11
Rep 685
Posts
Drives: 91 300ZX Twin-Turbo, 2010 135i
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Corpus Christi, Texas
|
No one builds a FI I6 like BMW either, that is kind of a bad point to make.......
I test drove a 128i without sport package, and it was too slow and floaty for my tastes.... Even a stock 135i is relatively slow. |
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 06:17 PM | #43 |
Private
10
Rep 94
Posts |
We have a 135i and a 328i. I really like them both, the 328 is a great car and I'd imagine that the 128 would be even better. I LOVE the gas mileage on our 328, on a recent 1500 mile trip, I average 31-34 MPG with the cruise control set at 86-89 MPH. I like the power of my 135i but honestly, who can use it out on the street? If I were to go to a 128, I doubt that I'd miss the extra "power".
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-17-2010, 08:05 PM | #44 | |
Captain
42
Rep 841
Posts |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
Post Reply |
Bookmarks |
|
|