View Single Post
      09-05-2011, 04:15 PM   #52
nachob
Brigadier General
United_States
2316
Rep
4,341
Posts

Drives: 2004 330i ZHP, 2022 Cayman T
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: California

iTrader: (5)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Crisp View Post
And?

He WANTED to pay $10k over sticker, he wasn't forced into it.
Do we see how each and every one of our cars are driven before they are in our hands?
Do we see how they are driven, or left idling, while they are in for service?

This one was caught on video so we can fight back against it, but you have to be careful what you ask for. Why would the dealer give back $10k when that was the agreed price for the car?

The owner is worried about reliability, correct? So you give the owner extended warranty to show that if something does go wrong, BMW stands behind their product.

Yes, it's not fair that the owner didn't get to launch the car before the dealer did, but as Mr. Europe said, most ED owners take their cars to the track as soon as they pick them up. Reliability is not the issue, we are just being immature and saying "it's my toy, i should have gotten to play with it first".
For that, you get an extended warranty, or $2k back, not an arm and a leg which you gave up for no reason to get this toy in the first place.

Just my opinion.
It's not worth your time and there should be more important things in life than this. Think of it this way, if there was no video, you wouldn't have known sh*t and you would have been in the same shoes as 99.9% of the rest of the world and BMW owners. You're not the first, nor are you the last to get something like this. Same sh*t will happen with your (and our) next car probably but it won't be on video.
All of this doesn't matter. The point is that the dealer knew this car had been improperly PDId and possibility of engine damage yet they sold it with no mention whatsoever as a new properly PDId car. That is the point the guy made. You say no one forced him to pay 10K over, but would he have paid 10K over if they told him the car had been abused during PDI? I don't think so. What people do with their own cars is their choice, good or bad but what happened here the dealer should have disclosed that something very improper happened to the car.

The issue is NOT whether the car is damaged, the issue is that they knowingly misrepresented a new cherry car for one that this probably not cherry.

On your point of people taking the car to the track, Nurburgring is about 300 miles. So even if someone decides to drive straight from Welt to Nurburgring, the car would at least be warmed up and have 300 miles of break in. This car was brand new non PDI and probably had less than 1 mile when abused.

Finally, there is a reason BMW says to take it easy on these cars for the first 1200 miles. They don't say that just for the heck of it. There IS a reason for it.....the parts have to seat correctly or they damage.

Period.
Appreciate 0