Bad Starter. Twice in a Row?

[t3harvinator]

Hi,

I have a 2013 135i with an N55 engine.

I was leaving McDonalds last week when the car wouldn't start.
It was a singular click sound when trying and the battery was good.
I even have a jumper box and hooked that up but no luck.

After some googling, I figured it was the starter. Code reads A0C1
I ordered a BMW Starter Motor - Valeo 438272 from FCP Euro.

I swapped it out and it started!! I started it like 5 times just to test it.
I went inside for a bit to clean up and then left to go get pizza to celebrate about a mile from my house.

Well, I was leaving the pizza place and it would not start again


I push started it and drove home but now I am stumped.
Would it be a bad starter again??? Did I just get unlucky??

Thanks for any thoughts on this.

[t3harvinator]

I'm dumbo. Bad positive connector. Similar to this guys thread.
https://www.1addicts.com/forums/show....php?t=1317003

Going to redo the connector!