E82: Coupe or Sedan

[Esteban]

Originally Posted by duder13

The E82 is a coupe. The question is should have BMW called the E82 a sedan?

Well, technically, the question of this thread is "do you think of the E82 as a coupe or a sedan?"

Your thread asks "is the 135i a sedan?" So maybe you should continue debating about it there... or here, if you like.

Or maybe you want to start another thread asking "should have BMW called the E82 a sedan?"

"Potato, potahto, tomato, tomahto, oh lets call the whole thing off."

[duder13]

Originally Posted by Esteban

Well, technically, the question of this thread is "do you think of the E82 as a coupe or a sedan?"

Your thread asks "is the 135i a sedan?" So maybe you should continue debating about it there... or here, if you like.

Or maybe you want to start another thread asking "should have BMW called the E82 a sedan?"

"Potato, potahto, tomato, tomahto, oh lets call the whole thing off."

I feel like this thread should continue, since it has legs.

If the tomato tomahto reference worked, I don’t think people would getting so worked up about their coupe being more of a sedan.

[dtla1]

I love how this is still on-going. Every couple of days I login, and boom, still talking about this.

Someone with good writing abilities should write a formal letter to BMW Corporate incorporating all of the evidence presented here and ask them to make an official decision on the designation of the E82

[Esteban]

Originally Posted by duder13

I feel like this thread should continue, since it has legs.

If the tomato tomahto reference worked, I don’t think people would getting so worked up about their coupe being more of a sedan.

I don't think anyone's getting worked up here, it's all for fun, at least to me, and the Last I checked not many people think their E82 is a sedan. At least the ones who voted.

[Esteban]

Originally Posted by dtla1

I love how this is still on-going. Every couple of days I login, and boom, still talking about this.

Someone with good writing abilities should write a formal letter to BMW Corporate incorporating all of the evidence presented here and ask them to make an official decision on the designation of the E82

Sounds like an entertaining idea. Not me though, I don't have good writing skills and I'm happy with what the E82 is currently called.

Maybe duder13 will volunteer. lol

[duder13]

Originally Posted by Esteban

I don't think anyone's getting worked up here, it's all for fun, at least to me, and the Last I checked not many people think their E82 is a sedan. At least the ones who voted.

Oh, I didn't mean worked up in a bad way. I hope we're all having fun talking about this kind of ridiculous topic.

I should start going to car shows to bug BMW reps about this!

[Esteban]

Originally Posted by duder13

Oh, I didn't mean worked up in a bad way.I hope we're all having fun talking about this kind of ridiculous topic.

Finally, we agree on something!

[duder13]

Originally Posted by Esteban

Finally, we agree on something!

Hey! I tend to agree with you on about 90% of the things you say around here...as long as it isn't coupes or exhaust!

[Esteban]

Originally Posted by duder13

Hey! I tend to agree with you on about 90% of the things you say around here...as long as it isn't coupes or exhaust!

The E82 is well documented as a coupe, and the sound of the PE is subjective. I love the sound but ymmv. lol

[Gangplank]

I'm changing my vote again. My new definition is that a Coupé has two doors, no more than 2+2 seat configuration, a short wheelbase & if fun to drive.

A sedan can have 2 or 4 doors but has 5 seats. Done.

[dtla1]

Coupe and Sedan side by side? You decide...

[Captain Blood]

I saw a BUNCH of 1'ers with 4 doors in Monaco this week. Wish I had had that choice in the US........

[gjm120]

my vote

[Esteban]

Originally Posted by Schwarzschild Radius

I saw a BUNCH of 1'ers with 4 doors in Monaco this week. Wish I had had that choice in the US........

Me too. I wouldn't mind at all having an M135i 4-door hatchback. I think it's cool.

[Captain Blood]

Originally Posted by Esteban

Me too. I wouldn't mind at all having an M135i 4-door hatchback. I think it's cool.

I'd buy that for a dollar!

[1mm2]

Originally Posted by Esteban

Me too. I wouldn't mind at all having an M135i 4-door hatchback. I think it's cool.

Not a fan.

[low135]

1 series sedan

[Esteban]

Originally Posted by low135

1 series sedan

https://www.motor1.com/news/250345/b...-sedan-mexico/

No likey...

[Smitty2]

Originally Posted by Esteban

Me too. I wouldn't mind at all having an M135i 4-door hatchback. I think it's cool.

plates are from my home state...


ps could be a 125i M4 door hatch too
we get weird stuff downunder